Choosing the right roofing materials for your repair in Newmarket makes the difference between a lasting fix and a job that needs doing again in a few years.
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.
When a roof repair is needed, one of the first questions homeowners ask is what it should be repaired with. The answer depends on what is already on the roof, the age of the property, and how long you want the repair to last. We cover roof repairs across Newmarket and the wider area, including slipped tiles and slates, failed flashings, leaking valleys, ridge and hip tile repairs, and chimney work. Before we quote, we inspect the roof properly so we are recommending the right material for the right situation.
The most important principle in a tile or slate repair is matching what is already there as closely as possible. A mismatch in colour, texture, or thickness creates a weak point because tiles of different profiles do not always interlock or lap correctly, which can let in wind-driven rain.
Natural slate is one of the trickier materials to match on older properties. Slate was quarried from several different regions, each producing a different texture and thickness. Welsh slate is typically blue-grey. Spanish slate tends to be darker and has a slightly different surface. Reclaimed Welsh slate is the best match for older Welsh slate roofs, but it can be harder to source in quantity. A good roofer will bring a sample to compare before ordering material.
Clay plain tiles vary considerably in colour depending on when and where they were made. On older properties, reclaimed tiles are often the only way to achieve a proper visual match. New handmade clay tiles are available and are excellent quality, but they come at a higher cost than machine-made alternatives.
Concrete interlocking tiles are generally easier to match by profile, because the same profiles have been manufactured for decades and spare tiles are widely available. Colour matching is less consistent because concrete weathers over time, so a new tile will often look noticeably different for the first few years.
Natural slate is one of the most durable roofing materials available. A good quality slate roof can last 80-100 years. Slate is thin and lightweight compared to clay or concrete, which is useful on older roof structures not designed to carry heavy loads.
The downsides are cost and availability. Natural slate costs more per tile than concrete, and finding matching reclaimed slate for a repair on a Victorian or Edwardian property takes more effort. There are also lower-quality imported slates on the market that have a much shorter lifespan, so it is worth asking where the material is sourced from.
Clay tiles are excellent in every respect except cost. They are fired at high temperatures and are essentially inert once cured, meaning they do not absorb moisture or degrade in the way concrete does. A clay tile roof, properly maintained, can outlast the building. The disadvantage is that good clay tiles are more expensive than concrete, and finding a close colour match for an older clay roof requires care.
Concrete tiles are the most widely used tile in the UK on post-war housing. They are cheaper to produce, widely available, and come in many profiles. They are heavier than slate or plain clay tiles, which was not always accounted for in the original roof structure on older properties. Over time, concrete tiles can develop a porous surface that absorbs moisture, which contributes to freeze-thaw damage. That said, a well-maintained concrete tile roof will last 40-60 years without needing replacement.
Lead is the standard material for flashings around chimneys, valleys between roof slopes, and abutments where a roof meets a wall. It is malleable, durable, and fully repairable. Lead correctly installed typically lasts 50-80 years, though it does require adequate fixings and expansion allowance to prevent cracking.
The main alternative to lead for flashings is a modern aluminium or lead-compatible flashing tape. These products are significantly cheaper and faster to fit, but they are not equivalent to lead in longevity. For a short-term repair they can be useful, but for a permanent fix on a chimney or valley, lead remains the preferred choice by most roofers and building surveyors.
Where a property has a flat roof section - common on extensions and rear additions - EPDM (ethylene propylene diene monomer) rubber is a widely used modern material. It is supplied in large sheets that are bonded to the roof deck, eliminating most of the seams that cause traditional felt to fail. EPDM is UV stable, flexible in cold temperatures, and typically carries a manufacturer's material lifespan expectation of 20-30 years or more.
Traditional torch-on felt is still used on flat roofs and remains a reliable option when correctly specified and installed with the right number of layers. It is generally less expensive than EPDM for smaller areas.
For a pitched tiled roof in the UK, natural slate and clay plain tiles are the most durable options available. Both outperform concrete in terms of longevity and moisture resistance. For repair work, however, the best material is whichever one matches the existing roof most closely and is appropriate for the structure carrying it. Specifying the most expensive material is not always the right answer if it means a poor visual match or an unnecessary structural load.
Costs depend on the material, the extent of the work, and whether scaffolding is needed. Typical current UK ranges:
Material choice affects cost. Natural slate and clay tiles cost more per unit than concrete. If you are having a larger area repaired or re-roofed, the material cost becomes a more significant part of the total.
A minor tile or flashing repair usually takes half a day to a full day on site. Larger repairs - valley relining, extensive ridge work, or chimney rebuilding - will take one to three days. Scaffolding erection and strike is arranged separately and typically adds a day at each end of the job.
Repair remains the right call when the majority of tiles or slates are structurally sound and the damage is localised. If the felt beneath the tiles is failing across the whole roof, the battens are rotten in multiple places, or more than a quarter of the tiles are cracked or porous, a full re-roof often works out cheaper over a ten-year period than repeated patch repairs.
An honest roofer will tell you which situation you are in after looking at the roof properly. Ask them to show you what they have found and explain their reasoning before you agree to any work.
Before any roofer starts work in Newmarket, ask them to confirm which material they are using, whether it matches the existing roof, and where it is sourced from. Ask whether scaffold is included in the quote, and whether the quote covers removing and disposing of old material. These are the details that sometimes get left out of a cheap initial price.
Call us to arrange a roof inspection in Newmarket. We will tell you what we find, what material we recommend, and why.
No obligation · We'll call you to arrange a free visit
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.
